Mexico has joined a legal challenge to Arizona's controversial new immigration law, Reuters News Service reported. The announcement comes in the wake of action by the Obama administration, which said it will challenge the Arizona law in federal court.
As our Los Angeles immigration lawyers have reported on our California Immigration Attorney Blog, the measure has been compared to California's Proposition 187. That measure attempted to refuse educational and social services to illegal immigrants and was ultimately ruled unconstitutional by the federal courts. We think the Arizona law could well suffer the same fate but, by then, much of the damage will have been done.
Authorities continue to report that residents of Mexican decent are leaving Arizona in droves. Border states, including California, will likely receive much of the influx. Kids will be taken out of school, jobs will be lost, financial boycotts will take their toll on the economy, and families will be uprooted. The Arizona law permits authorities to request identification from anyone suspected of being in the country illegally and to turn those found to be in violation over to federal authorities for deportation proceedings.
The law takes effect July 29. It is also being challenged in five separate lawsuits filed in federal court in Arizona by civil rights and religious organizations, as well as two police officers. Opponents argue the law is unconstitutional and is nothing more than mandated racial profiling.
The Mexican government has filed legal briefs in support of one of the lawsuits, saying the law "raises substantial challenges to the bilateral diplomatic relations between Mexico and the U.S." Mexico officials say more than 20 million Mexican workers, tourists and students were legally allowed in the United States throughout 2009 and it is concerned its citizens could be discriminated against based on racial profiling.
"Mexico is gravely concerned that (Arizona's law) will lead to .. detentions of Mexican citizens without regard to whether they have taken any actions or exhibited any behavior indicating they are guilty of a crime," the brief says.
The Latin America News Dispatch reports a challenge from the U.S. Department of Justice could be filed as early as next week. The federal lawsuit is expected to argue that Arizona doesn't have the constitutional right to make immigration policy and that the law could foster racial discrimination.
Arizona Gov. Jan Brewer said a legal defense fund has brought in $48,000 thus far and that those funds will be earmarked to defend the state against legal action. "I will ensure the immigration laws we passed are vigorously defended all the way to the United States Supreme Court if necessary," Brewer said.
Meanwhile, immigration reform advocates say lawmakers in the nation's capitol continue to expose the nation to independent actions taken by states to address immigration reform because the federal government has failed to enact legislation despite decades of debate.
On Monday, voters in Lincoln, Nebraska passed a measure that will penalize employers and landlords who hire illegal immigrants or allow them to rent apartments. The Journal Star reported that the American Civil Liberties Union and other organizations plan to fight the measure.
Continue reading "Mexican and U.S. governments fight Arizona's new immigration law " »